Binance, the world's largest cryptocurrency exchange, began restoring withdrawals in phases on 1 November, three days after attackers stole about $6.3 billion from its hot wallets — the largest cryptocurrency theft on record. The reopening became an immediate test of customer confidence: in the first nine and a half hours, users withdrew $4.649 billion while depositing $1.01 billion, leaving a net outflow of $3.64 billion. Binance presented that figure as reassuring — roughly 2.1% of its $171 billion in reported assets — while also warning that some transactions could still face delays as services return network by network.

Table of Contents

  1. A phased reopening, not a single switch
  2. The first nine hours in numbers
  3. "98% choose to stay": what the claim does and does not prove
  4. Replenishment is not recovery
  5. What is still unresolved
  6. Key takeaways
  7. Frequently Asked Questions
  8. Sources
  9. Chronicle further reading

A phased reopening, not a single switch

Binance did not flip every withdrawal back on at once. According to BeInCrypto, the exchange began restoring withdrawals at 06:00 UTC on 1 November, starting with Bitcoin, and then reopened networks one by one as security and operational checks were completed. By 12:36 UTC, withdrawals had resumed across all 15 networks in the initial phase, including Bitcoin, Ethereum, BNB Smart Chain, Solana, XRP Ledger, Tron, Arbitrum, Base and Optimism, as well as Polygon, Avalanche C-Chain, Zcash, TON, Sui and Dogecoin.

That sequencing matters. A single, simultaneous reopening after a breach of this size would have invited a crush of traffic and, worse, the risk of reopening a route that had not yet been checked. The phased approach let Binance watch volumes network by network — and it also meant that, for many users, "withdrawals are back" was true only for their particular asset and chain, not for everything on the platform. Additional networks and assets, including routes involving Cardano, Chainlink, Hyperliquid, Litecoin and NEAR, were still being tested, and US-dollar cash withdrawals were restored on 2 November, according to TechTimes.

Deposits, notably, had stayed available throughout the incident. That detail is easy to overlook, but it shaped the first day's numbers: money could flow in even while it could not flow out, so the reopening released several days of pent-up withdrawal demand at once.

The first nine hours in numbers

Binance's own figures for 06:00–15:30 UTC on 1 November tell a story of a sharp initial spike that then faded. As reported by the Financial Express, the exchange processed $4.649 billion in withdrawals and $1.01 billion in deposits in that window, for a net outflow of approximately $3.64 billion. The exchange said withdrawal volumes declined after an initial surge and were "stabilising as expected," with most of the movement concentrated in the first couple of hours.

The 2.1% comparison deserves a careful reading. It sets the $3.64 billion net outflow against $171 billion in total assets under management from Binance's proof-of-reserves data as of 28 October — a pre-attack snapshot, not a fresh measurement of what remained after the reopening. It is a useful scale check, not a solvency verdict: it shows the outflow was small relative to the exchange's reported size, but it says nothing, on its own, about the quality or liquidity of the assets backing customer balances.

Later reporting put the cumulative figure higher. TechTimes, citing Reuters, reported net outflows of $4.72 billion since the suspension was lifted — a reminder that the first nine hours were only the opening chapter, and that outflows continued as more networks reopened. Independent analytics firm DefiLlama was separately cited as reporting roughly $4.05 billion in net outflows over a 24-hour window around 1 November, a figure that differs from Binance's own because it measures on-chain flows rather than the exchange's internal books. The direction of all three measures is the same; the exact total depends on the window and the method.

"98% choose to stay": what the claim does and does not prove

Binance founder Changpeng Zhao, quoted by the Financial Express, summed up the first day in a single line: "12 hours after withdrawals resumed: 2.1% net outflow, with most occurring in the first couple of hours. Over $1 billion in flow, too." He added: "98% choose to stay!"

The slogan is doing a lot of work. If 98% of assets stayed, the exchange did not suffer a run — and for a business whose entire model rests on customers trusting it to hold their funds, avoiding a run after the largest theft in crypto history is a genuine achievement. But the figure also conceals as much as it reveals. It does not say how many individual users left versus stayed, how much of the remaining balance belongs to a small number of large holders, or whether outflows stabilised because confidence returned or because the users most inclined to leave had already left in the first hours. A net outflow that slows is consistent with both stories, and only the coming weeks will distinguish them.

There is also a structural point. Customers who withdrew may not have abandoned crypto at all — many will simply have moved funds to self-custody wallets or rival exchanges while they wait for the investigation to conclude. That is a loss of business for Binance, but not necessarily a loss of faith in digital assets as a class. The exchange's real test is not one day's outflow figure; it is whether trading volumes, deposits and new users recover over the next quarter.

Replenishment is not recovery

Binance has been emphatic that customers will not bear the losses. The exchange said it had set aside more than $6.34 billion and had already covered about 95% of the stolen funds from its own resources, including its treasury, insurance funds and security reserve, according to BeInCrypto. The remaining 5% consists of less liquid assets that will take longer to source, the company said, and it announced a new proof-of-reserves snapshot taken at 00:00 UTC on 31 October, with zero-knowledge-proof computation under way.

It is important to keep two different things apart here. Replenishment — Binance replacing missing holdings from its own pocket — is not the same as recovery, which would mean retrieving the stolen cryptocurrency itself. The original funds remain, as far as public reporting shows, in the hands of the attackers. Replenishment protects customers; it does not undo the crime, and it leaves Binance itself carrying a multi-billion-dollar hole that its reserves and insurance must absorb. Whether that hole is comfortably affordable depends on the true state of those reserves — which is precisely what a new proof of reserves is meant to demonstrate, and why its results will be scrutinised closely.

The attribution, meanwhile, is no longer in doubt at the official level. The FBI said on 31 October that North Korea's TraderTraitor group, an arm of the Lazarus Group, was responsible for the 29 October theft, and published hundreds of wallet addresses linked to the stolen funds, urging the industry to block transactions connected to them. The same group was blamed for the $1.5 billion Bybit hack in 2025 — the previous record, now dwarfed by a theft roughly four times larger.

What is still unresolved

Three questions will shape what happens next. First, how did the attackers get in? TechTimes reported that Binance co-chief executive Richard Teng had described a compromised laptop and malware designed to delete evidence, while a 30 October company update said an initial investigation suggested a laptop might have been involved but subsequent work had uncovered additional points of breach. Until the full technical account is published, other exchanges cannot be sure they have closed the same door.

Second, how much of the stolen money can actually be frozen? The FBI's address list is a powerful tool, but the attackers have already begun converting proceeds, principally into Ethereum, and moving them through decentralised finance and instant-swap services designed to obscure their trail. Every day that passes makes full recovery less likely.

Third, what will regulators do? A theft of this scale, at the world's largest exchange, will inevitably reopen debates about hot-wallet limits, internal access controls, disclosure timelines and whether exchanges of systemic size should face bank-like safeguards. Binance survived the first weekend. The regulatory aftermath will take far longer to play out — and it may matter more, in the end, than the first day's outflow figure.

Key takeaways

  • Binance restored withdrawals in phases from 06:00 UTC on 1 November, reaching all 15 networks in the initial phase by 12:36 UTC; not every asset and network reopened at once.
  • In the first nine and a half hours, withdrawals totalled $4.649 billion against $1.01 billion in deposits — a net outflow of $3.64 billion, about 2.1% of the $171 billion in assets reported before the attack.
  • Later Reuters reporting put cumulative net outflows at $4.72 billion, showing the outflow continued beyond the first day's window.
  • Binance says it has covered about 95% of the stolen funds from its own resources, with the remaining, less liquid 5% still to be sourced; replenishment protects customers but does not recover the stolen cryptocurrency.
  • The FBI has attributed the $6.3 billion theft to North Korea's TraderTraitor group and published hundreds of linked wallet addresses for the industry to block.
  • The open questions are the full breach mechanism, how much stolen money can be frozen, and what regulatory consequences follow for large exchanges.

Frequently Asked Questions

When did Binance restore withdrawals?

Binance began restoring withdrawals in phases at 06:00 UTC on 1 November 2026, three days after the 29 October theft, starting with Bitcoin and reopening networks one by one as checks were completed. By 12:36 UTC, all 15 networks in the initial phase had reopened.

How much money left Binance in the first hours?

In the first nine and a half hours (06:00–15:30 UTC on 1 November), Binance processed $4.649 billion in withdrawals and $1.01 billion in deposits, for a net outflow of approximately $3.64 billion. Later reporting cited by Reuters put cumulative net outflows at $4.72 billion since the suspension was lifted.

Does the $3.64 billion outflow mean Binance is in trouble?

Not on its own. The net outflow was about 2.1% of the $171 billion in assets Binance reported as of 28 October, and the exchange said volumes stabilised after an initial spike. But the figure is based on a pre-attack snapshot, and it does not by itself prove the health of the exchange's reserves — that will depend on the new proof of reserves and on whether outflows stay contained in the coming weeks.

Will Binance customers lose money from the hack?

Binance has said it will fully cover the financial impact of the theft and that customers will not bear the losses. It reported covering about 95% of the stolen amount from its own treasury, insurance funds and security reserve, with the remaining, less liquid 5% taking longer to source.

Who does the FBI blame for the hack?

The FBI attributed the theft to TraderTraitor, a North Korean hacking operation linked to the Lazarus Group, and published more than 600 Ethereum addresses, about 20 Bitcoin addresses and one Solana address linked to the stolen funds, urging exchanges and decentralised finance services to block related transactions.

Is this the largest cryptocurrency theft ever?

Yes, by a wide margin. At about $6.3 billion, the Binance theft is roughly four times the $1.5 billion Bybit hack of February 2025, which was the previous record and was also attributed to TraderTraitor.

Sources

Chronicle further reading